Principle

bedikotבְּדִיקוֹת

be-dee-KOT

The secondary examinations

The secondary examinations — open-ended detail-questions about the surrounding circumstances of an alleged crime, beyond the fixed seven chakirot. Unlike the chakirot, they have no set list, and a witness's 'I do not know' on a bedikah does not void the testimony, since refutation does not depend on such details. Their role is to surface contradictions: the more a judge multiplies them, the more praiseworthy, for they may expose a falsehood and clear an innocent defendant — as when ben Zakkai pressed witnesses on the very stems of figs.

Where it comes up

1 mishnah

  1. Sanhedrin 5:2Main questions versus side questionsThis mishnah defines the side questions — free-form questions to witnesses beyond the seven main ones — and praises the judge who multiplies them, since extra probing surfaces contradictions.