Object
aliyahעֲלִיָּה
A-LI-YAH
An upper story over another's house
An upper story or second-floor room built on top of a house, often owned or rented by someone other than the owner of the house below. Because the two levels rest on one structure, the law must work out how the owners share the building, the rebuilding after a collapse, and the duties of repair between them. The arrangement is the anchor case of the closing chapter of Bava Metzia, where a house and its aliyah, owned by two different people, fall and must be restored.
Where it comes up
3 mishnayot
- Bava Metzia 10:1Dividing the timber, stones, and earthThe whole perek revolves around an aliyah — an upper story built over another person's house, each owned by a different man. When the shared structure collapses, the two owners must sort out the wreckage and the rebuilding between them.
- Bava Metzia 10:2A broken upper-story floorHere the aliyah is rented out by the house-owner to a tenant. The landlord owes the tenant a usable upper story; if its floor breaks and he refuses to fix it, the tenant's remedy is to move into the house below.
- Bava Metzia 10:3Who rebuilds, and who pays rentThe upper owner cannot rebuild his aliyah until the lower house stands beneath it. So when the lower owner refuses to rebuild, the upper owner is stuck — and the mishnah works out how he may force the matter forward.